Fear Stages in Dogs
The Secondary Fear Stage in Dogs
The secondary fear stage (also called the second fear period) is a normal developmental phase in adolescent dogs. During this phase, a dog becomes unusually sensitive or cautious about its environment. It follows the primary (puppy) fear period (which occurs at about 8–11 weeks).
The secondary fear stage usually occurs around 6–14 months of age (timing varies by individual) . For example, small-breed dogs often enter this stage at the younger end (around 6–8 months), while larger breeds may not show it until 10–14+ months . Importantly, no amount of socialization can prevent these fear phases, as they are hardwired, evolutionary stages . In short, the secondary fear stage is the adolescent “teenage” phase of fearfulness – a temporary stage when even previously confident puppies may suddenly become uncertain about things around them .
Common Behavioral Signs
Dogs in the secondary fear stage often show sudden anxiety or wariness. Typical signs include:
• Increased wariness or startle response. The dog may become fearful of things it used to enjoy or tolerate . For example, a dog might begin cowering or avoiding objects, people or noises that were previously fine.
• Avoidance or hiding. The dog may back away, retreat or freeze when encountering triggers. Even familiar stimuli (e.g. a garbage can on a walk) can suddenly provoke fear – a dog might bark, raise its hackles and refuse to approach something it had seen many times before .
• Clinginess or uncertainty. Some dogs become more clingy to their owner or hesitant to explore, as if seeking safety. You may notice body language of stress (whining, lip-licking, trembling or hunched posture) in new situations or around triggers.
• Regression in training. Even reliably trained dogs may suddenly ignore cues or act “spooked.”
For example, a previously obedient 8-month-old might start ignoring recalls or jumping on visitors.
This is typically not naughtiness but anxiety under this stage .
• Variability: The intensity and signs can vary widely. Some dogs just become momentarily more cautious; others may be very reactive or anxious. Genetic temperament plays a role: breeds or bloodlines predisposed to nervousness often show more pronounced fear responses .
These behaviors usually start suddenly and are temporary. In many cases, a dog acts as if it “forgot” its confidence – running to hide at noises or avoiding toys it loved. Owners should recognize these as normal fear period behaviors, not willful disobedience .
Biological and Developmental Causes
The secondary fear stage has neurobiological roots.
During adolescence, a dog’s brain is rapidly reorganizing. Research shows that the frontal cortex (rational thought) temporarily loses some connectivity with the amygdala (the brain’s emotion/fear center) . At the same time, hormonal shifts (rises in cortisol and other stress hormones) make the puppy more sensitive to stimuli.
In effect, the puppy’s nervous system heightens its fight-or-flight response. This is partly adaptive: these “fear windows” teach the young dog what is truly dangerous so it can survive as an independent adult .
Key points in the biology of this stage include:
• Brain remodeling: Adolescence brings hormonal and neural changes. Areas involved in emotion (amygdala) become more reactive, while inhibitory control is still maturing.
• Hormonal surges: The onset of puberty triggers spikes in stress hormones (adrenaline, cortisol) that amplify fear and anxiety responses.
• Evolutionary purpose: Fear periods force the dog to relearn “what is safe.” A single traumatic experience during this time can create a permanent caution (an advantage if it’s genuinely life-threatening) . In practice, this means the dog can develop lasting fears if exposed to something frightening in this window.
• Independence drive: Like human teens, adolescent dogs are biologically programmed to test boundaries and become independent.
In nature, leaving the pack and fending for oneself is crucial; the brain is “preparing” for independence even though pets remain at home.
This mismatch can cause conflict: a fully-grown dog’s body with puppy-like logic can suddenly act insecure as it “learns” the world again .
In summary, the secondary fear stage results from normal developmental processes (brain maturation and hormones) that temporarily increase a puppy’s caution. It’s essentially an age-old survival mechanism playing out in modern pets .
Differences Across Breeds
Timing and intensity of the secondary fear stage can vary by breed and individual:
• Size and maturity: Smaller breeds usually mature faster than large or giant breeds . Consequently, many small dogs hit their secondary fear stage earlier (e.g. around 6–9 months), while large breeds may not enter it until 10–14 months or later.
• Genetic temperament: Some breeds have been selected for wariness or alertness (e.g. herding or guardian breeds). Dogs with a genetic predisposition to anxiety may show stronger or longer-lasting fear responses during these periods.
For instance, a breed known for nervousness might seem to slip into fear more easily than a very bold breed.
• Individual variation: Even within a breed, there’s no hard rule. Owners report that each dog’s fear periods are unique. Some dogs experience multiple fear spikes (one around 6 months, another around 12–18 months)
Others have just one pronounced episode. The exact age and duration can shift by months on either side, so owners shouldn’t expect a fixed schedule .
In practice, be alert that smaller breeds typically face this phase younger, and watch carefully for signs in any dog approaching adolescence. Genetic factors mean some dogs will naturally be more sensitive – regardless of breed, always tailor support to the individual animal.
Duration of the Stage
The acute secondary fear stage is usually brief. In most dogs, a fear period lasts only 2–3 weeks.
However, the overall adolescent fear phase can reoccur or linger:
• Single or multiple episodes: Some dogs have one clear secondary fear period; others may cycle through several episodes (for example, at 6–9 months and again at 10–14 months) . In total, fear phases may pop up anytime up to about 18–24 months of age.
• Extended sensitivity: While the peak is short, some dogs remain somewhat skittish for a longer stretch. Trainers note that in a few cases the hypersensitivity “lingers for several months” before fully resolving.
This typically fades as the dog reaches full adult maturity (often by 1½–2 years old, sooner in small dogs) .
In summary, expect the most intense fear reactions to last a few weeks, but watch for possible repeats or a more gradual decline in nervousness over several months.
Handling, Training and Socialization During This Stage
Use gentle, reward-based techniques. During the secondary fear stage, you want to help your dog feel safe and confident without forcing anything. Always let the dog set the pace. Allow the dog to retreat or investigate at will, and give lots of praise and treats for any brave behavior (like looking toward the scary object or staying calm)
Keep training sessions very short and fun – end on a positive note before your dog becomes overwhelmed.
• Avoid force or punishment. Never scold or physically push your dog toward a fear trigger. In fact, forcing a puppy to confront something scary can worsen the fear and make it long-lasting . Likewise, avoid any punishment or harsh corrections. These dogs are anxious – punitive methods will only deepen their anxiety.
• Gradual desensitization. If your dog is scared of a specific thing (thunder, vacuum, strangers, etc.), re-introduce it very slowly and under control.
For example, play a recording of the noise at a very low volume while the dog eats treats nearby . Reward any sign of relaxed curiosity. Repeat over days or weeks, slowly building tolerance.
• Structured socialization. Continue positive socialization in low-pressure settings. Gentle exposure to new people, dogs, places, and sounds is good – but keep it calm and controlled. For instance, meet a friend with a quiet dog on neutral ground rather than throwing your adolescent into a busy dog park.
Always monitor stress signals and give the dog breaks; you don’t want to overwhelm them.
• Positive association. Pair scary or uncertain situations with treats, toys or praise. If your dog is afraid of something, sit quietly a safe distance away and toss treats toward them as they observe the object or person . This counter-conditioning (pairing fear stimulus with rewards) helps them rebuild confidence.
• Maintain routine and security. Stick to your normal schedule as much as possible. Feed, walk and train as usual. Predictability helps an anxious dog feel secure. Provide safe spaces (crate or quiet room) where the dog can retreat. Reassure the dog with a calm voice and gentle petting – your steady presence is grounding.
• Avoid additional stressors. This is not the time for new traumatic experiences. Postpone non-essential vet visits (or find a fear-free clinic), avoid car trips if the dog panics, and certainly delay any scary grooming or medical procedures if possible. Remember: a single bad experience now can create a lifetime phobia.
• Seek expert help if needed. If your dog’s fear seems extreme or you’re unsure how to proceed, consult a certified dog trainer or veterinary behaviorist. A qualified professional can guide you through safe desensitization steps or recommend anxiety-reducing techniques .
Overall, patience and positivity are key. Treat your teenager like a scared kitten – keep calm, don’t pressure them, and reward bravery.
With consistent, gentle handling and lots of encouragement, most dogs come through the secondary fear stage just fine, often with newfound confidence.
In practice, reassurance and bonding go a long way. For example, calmly comforting a worried dog (as shown above) can help them feel safe. Quiet physical comfort (petting, gentle hugging) paired with treats or a favorite toy can remind the dog that good things happen even when they’re anxious. Staying a patient, steady “anchor” during this phase reassures your dog that the world is not going to overwhelm them .
Relation to the Primary Fear Stage and Development
The secondary fear stage is simply the second of two main fear periods dogs undergo, and both are integral to canine development. The first fear period happens early (around 8–11 weeks) just as puppies leave their litter . The secondary stage comes later, during adolescence (often 6–14 months) .
Both stages share similarities:
• Natural and temporary. Each fear period is a normal, short-lived phase. Puppies and adolescents will “snap out of it” after a few weeks . Owners should understand these reactions as developmental, not as permanent personality changes.
• Developmental milestones. The first fear period coincides with weaning and acclimation to a new home; the second coincides with puberty. In both cases, the brain is learning important life lessons (socialization early on, self-protection later). After each stage, dogs tend to emerge more confident and mature if experiences were managed well .
• Risk of imprinting. Both periods are “sensitive windows.” A negative experience (like pain or extreme fright) can leave a lifelong mark on the dog. This is sometimes called single-event learning . For example, a puppy scared by a vacuum in the first fear period might develop a lasting vacuum phobia; similarly, a teenager startled by a thunderstorm could remain fearful of storms. Protecting the dog in both stages is crucial.
• Long-term confidence. Successfully guiding a dog through these fear periods generally leads to a well-adjusted adult. Consistent positive experiences during puppyhood and adolescence build the foundation of a confident dog. In contrast, severe stress in either stage can contribute to chronic fears or behavior issues later .
In summary, the secondary fear stage is the later phase of fear sensitivity in a dog’s growth. Like the primary fear period, it is a natural pause in learning that prepares the young dog for adult life. With understanding and supportive handling, owners can help their dogs pass through this “teenage” phase and emerge as secure, well-socialized adults.
Here’s a clear, complete guide to fear stages in puppies, from birth through adolescence, written in practical terms trainers and owners use.
Fear Stages in Puppies (Complete Overview)
Puppies go through two main fear stages during development. These are normal, biological phases where the brain is highly sensitive to experiences.
If handled correctly, the puppy grows into a confident adult.
If handled poorly, fears can become permanent.
​
(1) Primary Fear Stage (First Fear Period)
When it happens
• 8–11 weeks of age
• Often occurs right after puppies go to new homes
Why it happens
• The puppy’s brain is learning what is safe vs dangerous
• Survival instinct turns on for the first time
• The nervous system is extremely impressionable
Common signs
• Sudden fear of:
• People (especially strangers)
• Loud noises
• New objects
• Freezing, hiding, trembling
• Startling easily
• Regression in confidence
Why this stage is critical
• Single-event learning is very strong here
• One bad experience (fall, scare, punishment, rough handling) can cause lifelong fear
How to handle it
• Keep experiences positive and gentle
• Do NOT:
• Force interactions
• Punish fear
• Flood with stimulation
• Use:
• Calm exposure
• Food, play, praise
• Short, successful experiences
This is NOT the time for harsh training or intense social pressure.
​
(2) Secondary Fear Stage (Adolescent Fear Period)
When it happens
• 6–14 months, depending on breed
• Small breeds: earlier
• Large / working breeds: later (10–18 months possible)
Why it happens
• Hormonal changes (puberty)
• Brain rewiring (emotion center > logic center)
• Dog is learning independence
Common signs
• Fear of things they were previously fine with
• Barking or avoidance of:
• People
• Dogs
• Noises
• Objects
• Clinginess or hesitation
• Training regression
How long it lasts
• Usually 2–4 weeks
• Can appear in multiple waves
How to handle it
• Stay calm and consistent
• Continue training, but lower expectations
• Reward confidence
• Avoid traumatic events
• Do not force exposure
​
(3) Minor Sensitivity Windows (Optional / Less Known)
Some puppies experience mini fear phases:
• Around 4–5 months
• During growth spurts
• After painful experiences (injury, illness)
These are usually short and mild but should still be handled carefully.
​
What NOT to Do During Any Fear Stage
• Do not punish fear responses
• Do not force the puppy “to face it”
• Do not overwhelm with crowds, chaos, or pressure
• Do not label the puppy as “bad” or “dominant”
Fear is emotion, not disobedience.
​
Best Practices Across All Fear Stages
Positive reinforcement
Gradual exposure
Calm leadership
Predictable routine
Safe spaces (crate, quiet room)
Short training sessions
Confidence-building games
​
Why This Matters Long-Term
Dogs that experience:
• Safety during fear stages → stable adults
• Trauma during fear stages → reactive or anxious adults
Fear stages are windows, not flaws.
​
Key Takeaway
Fear stages are normal, temporary, and necessary —
but how you handle them determines the dog you get.
Below is a professional, working-dog–specific guide. This is written the way decoy trainers, patrol K9 handlers, SAR trainers, and sport competitorsapproach fear stages—not pet-only advice.
I’ll break it into 4 clear sections and then show you how to tailor it to your dog.
​
FEAR STAGES IN WORKING DOGS
(Patrol, Sport, SAR, Protection, Detection)
Working dogs go through the same biological fear stages as pet dogs — but the stakes are higher because pressure, equipment, environments, and human expectations are greater.
​
(1) FEAR STAGES — WORKING DOG VERSION
Primary Fear Stage
8–11 weeks
What’s different in working dogs
• Puppies are exposed early to:
• Surfaces
• Noises
• Equipment
• Humans
• A bad experience here can permanently cap nerve strength
Danger zone
• Forced grip work
• Slippery surfaces without support
• Loud corrections
• Harsh environmental pressure
Goal
Create curiosity, not courage.
​
Secondary Fear Stage (MOST IMPORTANT)
6–14 months
(Large working breeds: often 9–18 months)
Why it hits working dogs harder
• Hormones surge
• Brain rewires
• Drive is high but nerves temporarily lag
• Dogs suddenly question pressure they previously ignored
Common working-dog signs
• Environmental hesitation (stairs, dark rooms, slick floors)
• Equipment sensitivity (sleeves, suits, harness)
• Sudden handler checking
• Vocal stress
• Grip avoidance or shallow grips
• Reduced aggression expression (not gone—suppressed)
This stage exposes weak nerves but does NOT create them.
​
(2) TRAINING PLANS FOR EACH FEAR STAGE
PRIMARY FEAR STAGE TRAINING (8–11 weeks)
DO
Play-based exposure
Food & toy pairing
Very short sessions
Neutral human contact
DO NOT
✘ No pressure
✘ No corrections
✘ No defense work
Sample Plan
• Walk on new surfaces → reward exploration
• Noise → food rain
• Equipment → sniff & disengage
• Tug = win immediately
End sessions early while confidence is high.
​
SECONDARY FEAR STAGE TRAINING (6–14+ months)
This is where good trainers separate from bad ones.
Rule #1: Never increase pressure
You maintain or slightly reduce pressure.
​
Obedience:
• Use known commands only
• No compulsion
• Pay heavily for compliance
​
Protection / Bite Work:
• Back to prey only
• Short wins
• No frontal pressure
• No civil aggression
• No testing nerve
If the dog hesitates → session ends on success
​
Environmental Work:
• Familiar environments first
• Re-teach surfaces
• One new variable at a time
​
Detection / SAR:
• Increase success rate
• Lower difficulty
• No stress stacking
​
Handler Rule
If you feel frustrated, stop the session.
​
(3) FEAR STAGE VS TRUE FEAR ISSUE (CRITICAL)
Fear Stage Indicators
* Sudden onset
* Dog was previously confident
* Appears in multiple contexts
* Comes and goes
*Improves with reduced pressure
True Fear Issue Indicators
✘ Present from puppyhood
✘ Intensifies over time
✘ Appears in the same situations consistently
✘ Avoidance behaviors increase
✘ Does not improve with confidence building
​
Quick Test (Used by Working-Dog Trainers)
Remove pressure for 2–3 weeks
• If confidence returns → fear stage
• If fear remains or worsens → genetic or learned fear issue
Pushing through a fear stage can CREATE a true fear problem.
​
​
GENERAL BREED GUIDELINES (QUICK)
• Malinois / Dutch Shepherd
• Fear stage often late (10–16 months)
• Mask fear with drive
• Biggest risk: handler overpressure
​
• GSD
• Longer fear windows
• Environmental sensitivity common
• Benefit from slower transitions
​
• Doberman
• Sharp fear spikes
• Sensitive to handler tone
​
• Rottweiler
• Slow maturity
• Confidence must be protected early
​
FINAL WORKING-DOG TAKEAWAY
Fear stages do not ruin dogs.
Trainers ruin dogs by mishandling fear stages.
Handled correctly, the dog comes out:
* Stronger
* More stable
* Clear-headed under pressure
Handled poorly:
✘ Environmental shutdown
✘ Equipment avoidance
✘ Weak grips
✘ Handler distrust
​
Below is a complete, professional working-dog framework you can apply to ANY breed, ANY age, ANY discipline.
This is how experienced trainers protect dogs through fear stages without softening them or ruining nerve.
​
(1) Week-by-Week Training Plan (8 weeks)
(2) Video Evaluation Checklist (what to look for)
(3) Wash vs Wait Decision Matrix
(4) Pressure Progression Charts
​
(1) WEEK-BY-WEEK PLAN (UNIVERSAL WORKING DOG)
This assumes a dog currently in or suspected to be in a fear stage.
​
WEEK 1–2: STABILIZATION PHASE
Goal: Remove pressure, restore confidence
What you DO
• Train only known behaviors
• High success rate (90%+)
• Short sessions (5–10 min)
• Familiar environments
• Food + toy reinforcement
• End sessions early on wins
What you DO NOT do
* No corrections
* No testing
* No new environments
* No civil pressure
* No handler frustration
If confidence does not improve by end of week 2 → flag for concern.
​
WEEK 3–4: CONFIDENCE REBUILD
Goal: Reintroduce mild challenge without pressure
Add:
• Slightly novel environments (same surfaces, new location)
• Low-level distractions
• Equipment re-exposure (no pressure)
Protection / Sport
• Prey only
• Short grips
• Immediate wins
• No frontal pressure
Detection / SAR
• Easy hides
• Clear wind
• Fast reward delivery
Dog should appear curious, not cautious.
​
WEEK 5–6: CONTROLLED STRESS INTRODUCTION
Goal: Teach recovery, not endurance
Add ONE variable at a time:
• New surface OR
• New sound OR
• New handler position
Stress → recovery → reward
✘ Stress stacking is forbidden
Handler Rule
If the dog needs encouragement more than once → stop.
​
WEEK 7–8: PRESSURE VALIDATION
Goal: Confirm readiness OR confirm wait/wash
Add:
• Moderate pressure
• Familiar decoy/helper
• Familiar environment
What you observe:
• Speed of recovery
• Grip quality
• Environmental scanning
• Handler independence
Dog should rebound within seconds, not minutes.
​
(2) VIDEO EVALUATION CHECKLIST (WHAT I WOULD LOOK FOR)
If you send video, here’s how I’d assess it:
NERVE & CONFIDENCE
Tail carriage consistent
Eyes forward, not scanning
Smooth movement
✘ Freezing
✘ Excessive sniffing
✘ Repeated disengagement
​
GRIP QUALITY (BITE WORK)
Full mouth
Calm push
No chewing
✘ Shallow grips
✘ Re-biting
✘ Vocal stress
​
HANDLER RELATIONSHIP
Works independently
Accepts direction calmly
✘ Constant handler checking
✘ Avoids proximity
✘ Stress whining near handler
​
WASH VS WAIT DECISION MATRIX (CRITICAL)
WAIT (DO NOT WASH) IF:
Dog was confident previously
Issue appeared suddenly
Improves when pressure drops
Fear appears in multiple contexts
Recovery speed improves weekly
​
WASH (OR REDIRECT) IF:
✘ Fear present since puppyhood
✘ Avoidance escalates over time
✘ No improvement after 6–8 weeks
✘ Environmental shutdown
✘ Equipment refusal persists
Rule:
Fear stages resolve. Nerve problems persist.
Never move up with any pressure unless the dog:
Recovers quickly
Maintains grip/task
Shows no avoidance
FINAL PROFESSIONAL TAKEAWAY
Strong dogs are built by protecting confidence first, then applying pressure later.
Fear stages:
• Reveal weaknesses
• Do NOT create them
• Can be navigated successfully with discipline and restraint
I hope you enjoyed reading our article on the different fear stages in dogs so you have a better understanding of what your dog may be experiencing.
​
​
Head Trainer: Michael Mc Cann
* We are an Approved Training Centre for Hadlow College, Students Working Towards Completing Their Animal Management Courses https://www.hadlow.ac.uk can do their required work placement with us.
* KCAI CD UK Kennel Club Accredited Instructor.
* Protrainings Approved Training Centre & Accredited Trainer for CFA.
* ABIADTB (Distinction) level 4 Advanced Behaviourist.
* Accredited Canine First Aider Instructor for level 2 & level 3 (VTQ). Michael Mc Cann K9 First Aider Instructor accreditation is endorsed by Training Qualifications UK an Ofqual Regulated Awarding Organisation, our K9 First Aider courses we deliver are endorsed by TQUK, an Awarding Organisation regulated by Ofqual.
* MtGodT Master Trainer Guild of Dog Trainers.
* Titled dogs at international level with the only Dobermann to gain 100p in tracking at an IGP3 trial under an FCI judge
* Highest points in Obedience at IGP3
* Highest points in Protection at IGP3
* Dutch Youth Working Champion
* Dutch Female Working Champion x 2
* Vice winner Dutch IGP Nationals
* Highest Titled Dobermann in the UK
* Accredited & Approved CPD Trainer.
* ADTIADTB (Distinction) (Advanced Dog Trainer)
* Accredited Trainer/Instructor & Approved Training Centre for IADTB.
* PTTLS Level 4 (Highest level) : Preparing to Teach in the Lifelong Learning Sector accreditation.
* FMNRDBT Founding Member National Register For Dog Behaviourists & Trainers.
* Cambridge Institute For Dog Trainers & Behaviourists (Advanced Professional Instructor Skills)
* AIIADTB (Distinction) (Advanced Training Instructor) International Academy For Dog Trainers & Behaviourists.
* Cambridge Institute For Dog Trainers & Behaviourists (Understanding Canine Care & Behaviour)
* MbiPdT Member British Institute Pet Dog Trainers.
* Cambridge Institute For Dog Trainers & Behaviourists (Professional Instructor Skills & Management)
* Kennel Club Good Citizen Dog Scheme Examiner.
* Cambridge Institute For Dog Trainers & Behaviourists (Certified Common Canine Behaviour Problems).
* National Association For Security Dog Users (General Purpose Security Dog Handler accredited).
* Previous National Association For Security Dog Users Instructor (Delivering their General Purpose Security Dog Handler level 2 & 3 courses).
* Cambridge Institute For Dog Trainers & Behaviourists (Understanding Canine Aggression)
Website: www.k9-ts.co.uk
Email: k9ts@yahoo.com
Mobile: 07496013382
Location:
The Olympic
Beechenlea Lane
Swanley,Kent
BR88DR
United Kingdom
Tel: 07496013382
Email: k9ts@yahoo.com
Subscription Link:
